West Virginia Judiciary

Opinions of the Supreme Court of Appeals - Spring 2009 Term

Spring 2009 Term Opinion List

 

Important Notice about filings in the Supreme CourtLinks to all decisions filed in the Spring 2009 term of court are listed in the table below.

Are you looking for an opinion list from a prior term of court? If so, please visit the Information & Search page. Opinions from the September 1991 term of court to the present day are available online.

January 2009 Term of Court Opinions
Date Filed Case No. Case Name
5/14/09 34811 State ex rel. J. W. v. Knight, Judge
6/5/09 34647 State ex rel. Knotts v. Facemire, Judge
3/03/09 34625 State ex rel. Freddie M., Jr. v. Eagloski, II, Judge (Memorandum Order)
8/19/09 34624 W. Va. Mandatory Continuing Legal Education v. Bennett, et al. (Per Curiam Order)
6/5/09 34618 State ex rel. Kutil and Hess v. Blake, Jr., Judge
5/4/09 34617 SER Board of Education of County of Putnam v. Beane, Judge
5/5/09 34617.Con SER Board of Education of County of Putnam v. Beane, Judge
3/27/09 34615 State ex rel. Nationwide Mutual v. Marks, Jr., Judge
5/4/09 34602 SER W. Va. Dept. of Health and Human Resources v. Pancake, Judge
7/27/09 34602.Con SER W. Va. Dept. of Health and Human Resources v. Pancake, Judge
2/27/09 34592 State ex rel. Office of Disciplinary Counsel v. Joan A. Mooney
2/3/09 34591 SER Ross Gray v. David Ballard, Warden, et al. (Memorandum Order)
2/6/09 34582 State ex rel. Khan Matin, M.D. v. Hon. Louis Bloom, Judge, etc.
5/19/09 34401 Pamela Gainer v. Martha Yeager Walker, Sec., W. Va. DHHR
7/27/09 34401.Con Pamela Gainer v. Martha Yeager Walker, Sec., W. Va. DHHR
6/22/09 34400 Clifford Crum v. Equity Inns, Inc., D/B/A The Hampton Inn, et al.
6/22/09 34400.Dis Clifford Crum v. Equity Inns, Inc., D/B/A The Hampton Inn, et al.
6/18/09 34399 Michael and Misty Blankenship v. The City of Charleston, etc.
6/23/09 34398 In Re: Jean Holly Dandy, A Protected Person
4/30/09 34368 Thomas D. Simpson v. W. Va. Ofc. of the Insurance Commissioner
4/30/09 34342 In Re: Maranda T.
618/09 34340 Euna Robinson v. James Pack
6/11/09 34332 Kenneth Dale Newman v. James E. Michel, Jr., etc.
5/13/09 34330 C & O Motors, Inc. v. West Virginia Paving, Inc.
5/4/09 34329 Chad R. Clower v. W. Va. Dept. of Motor Vehicles, etc.
6/11/09 34328 Sharon G. Noble v. W. Va. Dept. of Motor Vehicles, etc
3/31/09 34276 In Re: Tax Assessment Against Purple Turtle v. Gooden, Assessor
7/27/09 34276.Con In Re: Tax Assessment Against Purple Turtle v. Gooden, Assessor
6/22/09 34275 State of West Virginia v. Sheila G. Adkins
5/14/09 34273 Michael O'Dell Dennis v. State of W. Va., Division of Corrections
6/4/09 34272(Modified) George M. Peters v. Rivers Edge Mining, Inc.
6/5/09 34271 Catherine and John Smith v. Derek Andreini, M.D., etc.
6/5/09 34271.Con Catherine and John Smith v. Derek Andreini, M.D., etc.
6/9/09 34271.Con Catherine and John Smith v. Derek Andreini, M.D., etc.
5/19/09 34270 Jamey Little v. West Virginia Adjutant General
4/30/09 34269 Ann Morgan Zimmerer v. Mark E. Romano, et al.
6/4/09 34268 State of West Virginia v. Tanya D. Harden
7/27/09 34268.Dis State of West Virginia v. Tanya D. Harden
3/27/09 34267 CBC Holdings, LLC, et al. v. Dynatec Corp., USA, et al.
6/23/09 34266 State of West Virginia v. Danny Minigh
3/27/09 34265 Wells Fargo Bank v. UP Ventures II, LLC, et al.
5/19/09 34264 Jacob Frederick Jochum, Sr., etc. v. Waste Management of W. Va.
6/22/09 34262 Sue J. Erps and William G. Erps, etc. v. W. Va. Human Rights Comm.
2/27/09 34224 Ricky Drake v. Waco Oil & Gas Company, Inc.
3/31/09 34220 City of Bridgeport, et al. v. Robert Matheny
5/1/09 34219 State of West Virginia v. Joseph Fritache White
6/22/09 34218 In the Matter of: Petition of Carey L. B. for the Adoption, etc.
6/22/09 34160 Thomas D. Chenault v. Sharron K. Chenault
2/27/09 34159 State ex rel. Scott Edwards v. Linda L. Gibson, et al.
5/14/09 34158 State of West Virginia v. Michael S. Hutzler
3/12/09 34156 Freda Marlene Ratliff v. Norfolk Southern Railway
7/27/09 34156.Con Freda Marlene Ratliff v. Norfolk Southern Railway
3/12/09 34155 State ex rel. Dana December Smith v. Thomas McBride, Warden
6/22/09 34154 Builders' Service and Supply v. Christal M. Dempsey, etc.
4/30/09 34153 State of West Virginia v. Gary Wayne Kent
5/14/09 34152 Jennifer Boniey v. Brian Kuchinski, etc.
6/9/09 34151 Timberline Four Seasons Resort v. Pat J. Herlan, et al.
2/26/09 34150 Arden E. Fredeking v. Marlise Tyler, et al.
3/31/09 34147 Mark E. Smith v. Wesley Cross
5/13/09 34146 Dan's Carworld, LLC v. David Serian
2/6/09 34145 Ulissa Howell v. John Goode
5/4/09 34144 Jennifer L. Caruso v. Brian N. Pearce, et al.
5/4/09 34144.Dis Jennifer L. Caruso v. Brian N. Pearce, et al.
5/5/09 34144.Con Jennifer L. Caruso v. Brian N. Pearce, et al.
5/19/09 34143 Terry Hill v. Gregory Brent Stowers
6/23/09 34142 State of West Virginia v. Paul Newcomb
6/23/09 34142.Con State of West Virginia v. Paul Newcomb
2/5/09 34141 Trickett, et al. v. Laurita, Jr., et al.
3/27/09 34140 Kasserman and Bowman, PLLC v. Jane L. Cline
6/18/09 34139 Josephine Morgan v. Ford Motor Company, etc.
6/9/09 34138 Randy C. Huffman, Sec. DEP v. Goals Coal Co., etc.
6/9/09 34137 Russell Stuyvesant v. Preston County Commission
2/5/09 34136 State of West Virginia v. Ronald Reed, Sr.
5/1/09 34135 Ryan Strick v. Joseph Cicchirillo, Comm., W. Va. Div. of Motor Vehicles
1/30/09 33922 Norman Alderman v. Pocahontas County Board of Education
3/13/09 33919 State of West Virginia v. Billie Dawn Hatley
3/17/09 33919.Con State of West Virginia v. Billie Dawn Hatley
6/23/09 33918 J. H. v. W. Va. Division of Rehabilitation Services
7/27/09 33918.Con J. H. v. W. Va. Division of Rehabilitation Services
3/31/09 33913 Tammy Conley, Administratrix, etc. v. Jerry Stollings, et al.
2/6/09 33912 SER. W. Va. Dept. of Human Resources v. Timothy Ruckman, Judge
2/27/09 33911 State of West Virginia v. Jeff Corra
2/6/09 33910 Paul L. Ashbaugh v. Corporation of Bolivar, etc.
6/25/09 33909 Camden-Clark Memorial Hospital v. St. Paul Fire and Marine
6/22/09 33873 Darrell V. McGraw, Jr. v. The American Tobacco Company, et al.
5/1/09 33837&34327 Carl Wayne Vaughan v. Greater Huntington Park and Recreation
1/30/09 33835 State of West Virginia v. Gloria Jean Willett
3/20/09 33835.Con State of West Virginia v. Gloria Jean Willett
6/23/09 33811 Evelyn L. "Peach" Murphy v. Eastern American Energy, et al.
1/30/09 33803 Raines Imports v. American Honda Motor Company
6/22/09 33730 SER Deborah Harper-Adams v. Donna Sue Murray, etc.
6/23/09 33600 In Re: Daniel R. James
5/6/09 33516 Lawyer Disciplinary Board v. Raymond David Brown, Jr.
5/6/09 33516.Dis Lawyer Disciplinary Board v. Raymond David Brown, Jr.