Link to PDF file

No. 31042 --SER Brooks v. Zakaib

McGraw, J., dissenting:

        I fail to see how something that is no longer privileged, because it was published, or a doctor waived his or her privilege, can ever become privileged again. While the Circuit Court of Grant County theoretically could have sealed the information, if it did not seal it, I do not believe the Circuit Court of Kanawha County would have that power in this case.

        Unless one entitled to a privilege assiduously guards it by requesting protective orders when confidential information is used in open court, I cannot see how a second court could “recover” the lost confidentiality. Simply stated, short of mass hypnosis, the genie can't be put back in the bottle.
                                    
        For the reasons stated, I must respectfully dissent.