Link to PDF file
No. 34598 - In re: Ryan B.
No. 34704 - In re: Caitlyn M., Carson M., and Steven M.
Benjamin, Chief Justice, concurring:
I write separately to underscore the procedure set forth in Syllabus Point 2
herein, by which a circuit court retains the discretion in specific cases not to order a
terminated parent to pay child support if that is what is in the child's best interests (based on
factors such as permanency, etc.). Quite obviously, the overriding principle is to act in the
child's best interests. While the majority opinion establishes a presumption that a terminated
parent continue to pay child support pursuant to the Guidelines for Child Support Awards
found in W.Va. Code § 48-13-101, et seq. (2001), that presumption is subject to the best
interests of the child. Should the court determine that the presumption should not be
followed in a specific case, the court should make such a finding on the record with its
reasons clearly set forth in its order.