Link to PDF file

No. 26736_Melanie L. Minshall v. Health Care & Retirement Corp. of America

McGraw, J., dissenting:

        I disagree with the majority's assessment of the substance of appellant's claim. The gravamen of Ms. Minshall's charge is that she was treated more harshly because she is a woman. Although the basis for this claim is somewhat tenuous, Ms. Minshall should nevertheless be permitted to put her case before a jury. I therefore respectfully dissent.